Open research questions in Healthcare Decision-Making and Restraints
356 gap statements mined from Healthcare Decision-Making and Restraints papers in our 7.9M-paper local library, which holds 2,352 papers on the topic — drawn mostly from each paper's own stated research gap, future-work, challenge and limitation notes, and its abstract. The ones listed below are a selection still marked open; each names the study that raised it, with a DOI link where the paper has one.
Choosing where to publish on Healthcare Decision-Making and Restraints? See the ranked Psychology journals.
What the literature leaves open
The legal reform coincided with the COVID-19 pandemic, which may have confounded the results. Differential pandemic effects across age groups and countries cannot be excluded. The study's findings may be limited by the use of a single region in Sweden and the lack of data on other potential confounders.
Impact of legislative reform on coercive measure use in child and adolescent psychiatry: A controlled interrupted time series analysis · 2026 · DOILimited evidence on the effectiveness of legislative reforms in reducing coercive measure use. A need for studies evaluating the impact of legislative changes on coercive measure use in child and adolescent psychiatry. A lack of controlled interrupted time series studies examining the effects of legislative reforms on coercive measure use.
Impact of legislative reform on coercive measure use in child and adolescent psychiatry: A controlled interrupted time series analysis · 2026 · DOIThe findings showed that physical restraint elicited diverse thoughts and emotions among nurses, who reported difficulties in coping with these emotions and insufficient knowledge of restraint procedures.
Experiences of Intensive Care Nurses in Their Practice of Physical Restraint Among Patients: A Qualitative Study · 2026 · DOIDe-escalation is recommended as the first-line, least restrictive response to agitation and aggression in acute psychosis, yet randomized evidence for the technique itself remains scarce.
However, the process of implementing this legislation into practice remains unclear for therapists.
Assessment of older adults' decision‐making capacity for independent living: Findings from a nominal group technique meeting in Ireland · 2025 · DOIResearch data on the extent of and protocols related to physical restraint (PR) in pediatric intensive care units (PICUs) are scarce.
Physical Restraint in a Pediatric Intensive Care Unit: A Cross-Sectional, Observational Study in China · 2025 · DOIThere is a lack of explicit recognition of supported decision-making in federal research regulations. There are legal barriers to the greater use of supported decision-making.
The Legal Landscape for Supported Decision-Making in the United States and its Application to Clinical Research · 2026 · DOIFuture research should focus on multisite and mixed-methods studies to examine the prevalence, determinants, and outcomes of restraint, evaluate the effectiveness and implementation of restraint-reduction strategies and alternatives in resource-limited settings, and generate comparative evidence across Tanzania and sub-Saharan Africa to inform context-appropriate, rights-based policies and practice.
Patients’ experiences and perceptions of physical restraint in psychiatric care: A descriptive qualitative study at Muhimbili National Hospital · 2026 · DOIThe challenge of making decisions for patients who lack decision-making capacity. The challenge of balancing the patient's autonomy with their need for care.
Future research should investigate the implementation of epistemic adequacy in mental health systems. Future research should examine the impact of artificial intelligence on epistemic adequacy in mental health. Future research should explore the development of criteria for functional adequacy and cross-context consistency.
The possibility that surrogate authority may be exercised by proxies whose motives are shaped by financial or personal self-interest has received limited attention in the philosophical literature. The structural vulnerability of the substituted judgment standard has not been fully addressed.
Autonomy under uncertainty: the structural limits of substituted judgment in clinical practice · 2026 · DOIThe gap between statutory rule and everyday medical activity remains in the operation of the informed-consent rule. The existing literature has not adequately addressed the practical dilemmas in the operation of the Civil Code's informed-consent rule.
Practical dilemmas and communication reconstruction of patients' right to informed consent under the Civil Code · 2026 · DOIThe study highlights the need for further research on the effectiveness of digital platforms in providing mental health services.
Analysis of the Implementation of the Rights of Patients with Mental Disorders to Access Health Services in HospitalsProf. Dr. Muhammad Ildrem North Sumatra · 2026 · DOIThe study faced challenges in developing a brief and pragmatic assessment tool that could be applied in the immediate perioperative workflow. The study had to balance the need for a standardized questionnaire with the need for a tool that could be tailored to both elective and trauma settings.
Informed Consent in Orthopaedic Surgery: When a Signature Does Not Mean Understanding: A Prospective Study of 750 Patients Comparing Elective and Trauma Settings · 2026 · DOIThe extent to which patients truly understand surgical information in the perioperative setting remains uncertain. Limited comprehension of surgical informed consent may be particularly problematic in orthopaedic surgery, where trauma pathways are often characterized by urgency, pain, and emotional stress.
Informed Consent in Orthopaedic Surgery: When a Signature Does Not Mean Understanding: A Prospective Study of 750 Patients Comparing Elective and Trauma Settings · 2026 · DOIThe gap between the current functionalised model of care and the need for continuity of care. The lack of comprehensive knowledge of the patient's history in critical decision-making.
Patients with femur fractures often experience anxiety due to limited understanding of the procedure, risks, and outcomes of surgery. Healthcare professionals face challenges in providing proper implementation of informed consent procedures.
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CONSENT AND ANXIETY IN PATIENTS WITH FEMUR FRACTURES AT RADEN MATTAHER HOSPITAL · 2026 · DOIImportance: The effect of wrist-strap physical restraints on outcomes in patients receiving mechanical ventilation in the intensive care unit (ICU) remains uncertain.
The study had to address the issue of lacking a dedicated pediatric psychiatric inpatient unit, with patients requiring inpatient admission being boarded in the ED pending transfer to external facilities.
Age-Dependent Restraint Patterns in Pediatric Emergency Department Patients With Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Brief Report · 2026 · DOIThere is a lack of age-stratified examination of restraint use in pediatric ED patients with ASD. The study aims to address this gap by analyzing restraint patterns in this population. The paper provides new insights into the developmental patterns of restraint use in pediatric ED patients with ASD.
Age-Dependent Restraint Patterns in Pediatric Emergency Department Patients With Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Brief Report · 2026 · DOIInvoluntary hospitalisation rates vary greatly across Europe, but the effects of this phenomenon have been poorly studied.
Expanding involuntary hospitalization is not sufficient to support long-term treatment for people with severe mental health issues.
Rather than determining what is objectively best for the patient — the alternative best interests standard — it requires the surrogate to reconstruct the decision the patient would have made under current circumstances. The normative ambition 1 3B.
Autonomy under uncertainty: the structural limits of substituted judgment in clinical practice · 2026 · DOIMost state EMS protocols do not include modifications or specific guidance for older adults. None of the protocols reviewed provide modifications to guidance for physical restraint use, prioritization between physical restraint and chemical sedation, or sedative medication selection when treating older adults.
Exploring Current Emergency Medical Services Approaches to Manage Agitated Older Adult Patients: An Analysis of Statewide Protocols · 2026 · DOIThe paper identifies a gap between normative commitments and clinical reality in mental health. The paper identifies a gap in the system's capacity for context-sensitive judgment. The paper identifies a gap in the consideration of epistemic adequacy in decision-making processes.
Most-cited papers in Healthcare Decision-Making and Restraints
- Coming to Terms With the Terms of Risk · Archives of General Psychiatry · 1997 · 1,085 citations
- Dropping out of treatment: A critical review. · Psychological Bulletin · 1975 · 769 citations
- Patient non-compliance: Deviance or reasoned decision-making? · Social Science & Medicine · 1992 · 569 citations
- A New Brief Instrument for Assessing Decisional Capacity for Clinical Research · Archives of General Psychiatry · 2007 · 558 citations
- Tests of competency to consent to treatment · American Journal of Psychiatry · 1977 · 447 citations
- THE PSYCHIATRIC NURSE AS A BEHAVIORAL ENGINEER1 · Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior · 1959 · 407 citations
- Critical dimensions in the choice and maintenance of successful treatments: Strength, integrity, and effectiveness. · Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · 1981 · 397 citations
- Patient-focused research: Using patient outcome data to enhance treatment effects. · Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology · 2001 · 361 citations
- Reducing conflict and containment rates on acute psychiatric wards: The Safewards cluster randomised controlled trial · International Journal of Nursing Studies · 2015 · 344 citations
- Assessing Decisional Capacity for Clinical Research or Treatment: A Review of Instruments · American Journal of Psychiatry · 2006 · 337 citations
Most recent work
- Restrictive vs Liberal Physical Restraint Strategies in Critically Ill Patients · JAMA · 2026
- Examining Better Access use by Australian adults using data from two longitudinal studies (Ten to Men and the Australian Longitudinal Study on Women’s Health) · Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry · 2026
- Perspectives and Experiences of Nurses Implementing the Safe Steps for De‐Escalation in Acute Mental Health Units · Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing · 2026
- The Prevalence and Characteristics of Difficult Patient Encounters · Annals of Internal Medicine · 2026
- The Protective Paradox: When the Shield Becomes the Wound. Institutional Bifurcation, Statutory Breach, and the Systematic Abandonment of Neurodivergent Individuals by the Systems Designed to Protect Them · Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) · 2026
- Abolition of coercion in psychiatry on the horizon? A descriptive ecologic data study from six European countries · European Psychiatry · 2026
- Factors influencing the outcomes of Community Treatment Orders: state-wide study using linked administrative health data from New South Wales, Australia · BJPsych Open · 2026
- The Legal Landscape for Supported Decision-Making in the United States and its Application to Clinical Research · Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics · 2026
- Capacity to give informed consent in patients with severe mental disorder in different treatment settings · Frontiers in Psychiatry · 2026
- Psychiatric advance directives: challenges emerging from implementation and possible steps forward · World Psychiatry · 2026
Find a gap in your own Healthcare Decision-Making and Restraints sub-topic
This page shows what the Healthcare Decision-Making and Restraints literature already flags as unresolved. To narrow it to your specific question, search the Research Gap Finder: the search is free with a free account and lists the papers closest to your topic first. Unlocking that topic (50 credits, charged once) fills the comparison table from our 7.9M-paper local library and writes the gaps from its rows.
Open the Research Gap Finder →